이인규
아무리 생각해도 참으로 이상한 주장이다.
대외적으로는 이미 고쳤다고 주장하는데, 대내적으로는 아무 문제가 없다고 주장한다.
이러한 두가지 말은 스스로 오류와 모순을 말하는 것이 된다.
고쳤다는 것은 과거에 잘못된 것이 있었다는 것을 인정하는 것이기 때문이다. 아무 문제가 없는데 고치는 사람은 바보일 것이며, 고쳤다는 자제가 스스로 잘못을 인정하는 내용이다.
게다가 잘못을 인정하고 고치겠다는 사과성명서까지 발표했다. 그런데도 여전히 한편으로는 잘못이 없다고 한다.
그리고 우리나라의 수천교회에서 잘못된 내용의 두날개를 도입하여 가르쳤다면, 무엇이 잘못이었고 어떻게 수정하여야 한다는 것을 알려 주어서, 그 잘못된 점을 고쳐나가야만 하지 않는가? 요즈음은 자동차 회사에서도 아무 문제가 나타나지 않아도 잘못의 가능성이 있다면 리콜을 하여 미리 고쳐준다.
두날개는 스스로 교재를 고쳤으므로 더 이상 따지지 말라고 주장한다. 주객이 전도가 된 느낌이다. 필자는 이러한 주객전도의 주장을 두날개 신드롬이라고 부르고 싶다.
합신에서 공청회를 통하여 잘못된 점을 토론하자고 하는 것은 아주 건전한 제안이라고 생각한다. 두날개가 잘못된 점을 스스로 고치겠다는 자정과 개선의 의지를 갖고 있다면, 자발적으로 공청회에 참여하여야만 한다. 가능한 넉넉한 시간을 두고 많은 사람들이 참여를 하여야 한다고 생각한다. 그래야만 두날개의 문제점에 대해서 무엇이 잘못이고 무엇이 오해인지를 알게 되는 귀중한 기회가 될 것이다.
그럼에도 불구하고 갖은 변명으로 공청회를 참여하지도 않으면서, 정당한 절차인 공청회를 마치 불법인 것처럼 매도하며, 정치적인 압력을 가하는 이유는 두날개가 스스로 자정의 능력이 없으며, 고치겠다는 자발적인 의지가 없다는 것을 말하여 준다.
누가보아도 두날개는 고치겠다는 의지보다는 외부로 감추려는 의도가 먼저이기 때문이다. 그러나 필자가 보기에는, 바둑 용어를 빌리자면 두날개는 악수를 두고 말았다.
G12와 두날개, 그리고 이와 유사한 불건전한 신사도운동적인 셀 운동은 한국교회의 신학적인 질을 유치한 수준으로 떨어트렸으며, 자칭 영성운동이라는 무절제한 이름으로 신학부재의 혼돈상태까지 초래하였다. 아주 쉽게 말하자면 개교회의 교인 숫자를 늘리기 위한 목적으로 한국교회 전체를 망가트렸다. 이러한 운동을 한국교회에 도입한 목사들은 반드시 그 책임을 지어야만 한다.
현재 많은 신학자들과 교수들이 신사도운동과 그 유사운동에 대해서, 셀운동에 대해서 비판과 경고를 하고 있다. 한국교회는 성경공부라는 명목으로 이단들이 많은 영혼들을 미혹했고, 그 뒤로 G12. 두날개, 셀운동이라는 이름으로 많은 성도들의 신앙을 망가트려 버렸다. 한국교회의 머리는 더이상 예수가 아니라 목사가 되고 말았으며, 소위 영성운동은 유치하게도 쓰러짐과 넘어짐의 현상적인 집회와 귀신축사와 병고침이 되고 말았으며, 성도들의 신앙은 기복적이며 무속적인 성향으로 변질되다 못하여 물질적인 축복을 위한 굿내림이 되고 말았다.
오늘날 대부분의 한국교회는 성경공부 가르치기에 관심이 없고, 또한 건전한 정통신학 가르치기에 대해서 관심이 없다. 오직 교회는 교인들의 외형 숫자 불리기에만 관심이 있기 때문이다. 850만명의 개신교 인구 중에서 200만명이 이단에 빠졌다고 한다. 이 책임의 원인이 되는 목사들과 교회들이 그 책임에 대해서 무관심하다.
두날개 신드롬은 참으로 심각하다.
신문사와 방송국들은 후원금 몇푼에 그 사명과 자정의 능력을 잃었고, 비판의 붓을 이미 꺾어 버렸고, 교단들은 자기 날개에 있는 소속교회를 감싸안고 보호하기 위하여 복음의 능력을 상실하였다. 이단연구가들은 더 이상 이단연구를 하지 않으며, 교단들은 성추행을 했건 횡령을 했건 실정법을 어겼던 그것은 더 이상 문제를 삼지 않는다. 다만 중요한 것은 단체의 크기와 교인들의 숫자일 뿐이다. 다른 예수와 다른 영, 다른 복음을 전하여도 아무 문제가 없다. 오히려 ‘라이언 일병 구하기’가 시작되었다.
두날개 신드롬은 현재 불치의 병이 되고 말았다.
"화 있을진저 너희 지금 배부른 자여 너희는 주리리로다 화 있을진저 너희 지금 웃는 자여 너희가 애통하며 울리로다. 모든 사람이 너희를 칭찬하면 화가 있도다 그들의 조상들이 거짓 선지자들에게 이와 같이 하였느니라"(눅 6:25-26)
I polo ralph lauren outlet found ray ban it cheap oakley sunglasses not charlotte hornets jersey difficult, nfl cowboys in polo ralph the nfl broncos excitement chi hair of salomon schuhe Mr. ray ban sunglasses Chillip's toms shoes outlet ownbrain, nfl eagles under nike free shoes his prada outlet potations nike air max of adidas superstar negus, air max 90 to katespade outlet divert barbour outlet his kate spade attention north face jackets fromthis ralph lauren uk topic dre beats to cheap basketball shoes his air max shoes own pistons jersey affairs, supra footwear on beats audio which, pandora rings for salvatore ferragamo the nop jerseys next cheap michael kors half-hour, nfl vikings hewas moncler outlet online quite giuseppe zanotti loquacious; michael kors outlet online giving swarovski crystal me nfl 49ers to adidas neo understand, coach black friday among free run other barbour mens jackets piecesof iphone 5 cases information, ray ban sunglasses outlet that roshe run he dsquared2 shoes was nfl patriots then ray ban zonnebril at versace shoes outlet the michael kors Gray's oakley sunglasses outlet Inn longchamp Coffee-house cheap jerseys tolay the north face his free running professional abercrombie evidence longchamp handbags before michael kors outlet online a michael kors outlet Commission hermes bags of polo ralph lauren outlet online Lunacy,touching utah jazz the adidas sneakers state moncler women jackets of oakley sunglasses outlet mind vans schuhe of oakley a jordan shoes patient nike air who abercrombie and fitch kids had burberry become new balance store derangedfrom nike free shoes excessive nfl rams drinking.
'And michael kors outlet I roshes assure nike air max you, air max 2015 sir,' nfl dolphins he cheap jerseys said, kobe bryant jersey 'I burberry handbags am vans shoes extremely burberry online shop nervous vibram shoes on northface suchoccasions. celine black friday I swarovski could barbour mens jackets not michael kors bags support asics gel being long champ what ralph lauren is michaelkors.com called knicks jerseys Bullied, ugg australia sir.It nike huaraches would michael kors quite nba jerseys unman louboutin me. ray ban outlet Do swarovski you nike outlet know burberry outlet online it minnesota timberwolves was coach outlet sale some mia jersey time toms outlet before adidas Irecovered abercrombie fitch the sac jerseys conduct ugg boots of burberry outlet that uggs alarming timberland outlet lady, swarovski jewelry on prada outlet the nfl panthers night celine handbags of christian louboutin shoes yourbirth, occhiali oakley Mr. thomas sabo Copperfield?'
I hollister clothing store told ralph lauren black friday him fake rolex that tory burch sale I portland trail blazers was ralph lauren outlet going ralph lauren down nike mercurial vapor to nike air my air jordan retro aunt, michael kors the givenchy bags outlet Dragon michael kors bags of suns jerseys thatnight, nike huarache early tommy hilfiger in nike outlet the uggs outlet morning; cheap eyeglasses and air jordan shoes that red bottoms she baseball bats was lunette oakley pas cher one lacoste polos of nba jerseys the uggs black friday mosttender-hearted air max and thomas sabo uk excellent gafas oakley of philadelphia 76ers jersey women, michael kors outlet as air jordans he the north face would rolex know nike mercurial full mcm handbags wellif polo outlet online he nfl jerseys knew jerseys from china her timberland boots better. indiana pacers The russell westbrook jersey mere hollister online shop deutschland notion cheap oakley of gooses the toms shoes possibility jerseys from china of nfl browns hisever bcbg max azria seeing toronto raptors her michael kors v?skor again, relojes especiales appeared timberland shoes to armani clothing terrify cheap nike shoes him. air max 95 He coach black friday replied nfl raiders with tommy hilfiger asmall kate spade outlet pale designer handbags smile, adidas.de 'Is hugo boss outlet she mcm backpack outlet so, kate spade outlet online indeed, burberry handbags sir? tommy hilfiger outlet stores Really?' toms outlet and christian louboutin almostimmediately cheap glasses called giuseppe shoes for oakley a uhren candle, tory burch shoes and adidas shoes went michael kors bags to tory burch sandals bed, ray ban sunglasses as abercrombie.com if ferragamo he www.tommyhilfiger.nl were ugg australia notquite swarovski safe cheap oakley anywhere michael kors australia else. chicago bulls He nike.dk did coach outlet not michael kors black friday actually true religion jeans women stagger vans outlet under nfl titans thenegus; replica watches but louboutin outlet I uggs should ray ban sunglasses think nfl bills his hermes birkin placid nfl steelers little nfl bears pulse bottega must nfl giants have chrome hearts jewelry madetwo burberry outlet online or pandora jewellery three burberry bags outlet more gsw jerseys beats coach factory outlet online in louboutin a hair straightener minute, tory burch shoes than ralph lauren polo it oakley had pandora bracelets done oakley sunglasses cheap since nike roshe thegreat uggs night uggs outlet of zapatillas nike my houston rockets aunt's reebok disappointment, ugg when nfl chargers she michael kors outlet online struck nfl seahawks at pandora himwith ralph lauren outlet her ray ban outlet bonnet.
Thoroughly nike tn requin tired, nike free run I beats by dre went p90x workout schedule to insanity calendar bed babyliss too, cheap oakley sunglasses at replica watches midnight; burberry uk passed polo ralph lauren outlet the hilfiger nextday nike outlet on roche run the burberry sale Dover instyler ionic styler coach; air jordan burst louboutins safe kanye west shoes and nike store sound nfl colts into marc jacobs handbags my oakley sunglasses aunt's dallas mavericks jersey oldparlour polo ralph lauren while replica rolex she oakley outlet online was hilfiger outlet at shoes on sale tea nike outlet store (she north face backpacks wore swarovski australia spectacles ralph lauren online now); wholesale handbags and coach handbags outlet wasreceived jordan release dates by ray ban her, soccer shoes and nike.de Mr. memphis grizzlies Dick, montre pas cher and nfl jaguars dear michael kors purses old new balance Peggotty, jordans for sale who jerseys from china acted coach outlet online ashousekeeper, ray bans with timberland homme open coach factory outlet online arms bottega veneta and converse tears lunette ray ban pas cher of michael kors outlet online sale joy. uggaustralia.com My roshe run aunt nba jerseys was nike.se mightilyamused, new balance when longchamp black friday we rolex replica began toms shoes to nfl chiefs talk watches composedly, michael kors handbags by nike air max 2014 my nfl bengals account coach black friday of toms outlet mymeeting replica watches with michael kors handbags Mr. valentino shoes outlet Chillip, jimmy choo shoes and ua stephen curry of pandora his adidas shoes outlet holding coach bags her converse outlet in converse chucks such softball bats dreadremembrance; the north face outlet and coach outlet both guess jeans she nfl redskins and barbour women jackets Peggotty barbour women jackets had mizuno running shoes a san antonio spurs great nike air force deal converse shoes to michael kors handbags sayabout longchamp taschen my philipp plein clothes poor ralph lauren outlet online mother's abercrombie and fitch second mcm bags husband, michael kors and adidas.se 'that burberry handbags murdering cleveland cavaliers jerseys woman replica handbags ofa cheap ray ban sister', ray ban sunglasses - nfl azcardinals on ugg boots clearance whom cheap oakley sunglasses I juicy couture think iphone 4s cases no oakley black friday pain orlando magic or ray ban black friday penalty oakley sunglasses would ferragamo shoes have denver nuggets inducedmy nike air max aunt wedding dresses uk to nfl falcons bestow new balance shoes any huaraches Christian pandora or coach factory outlet online Proper mbt shoes outlet Name, burberry or mcm bags any ray ban otherdesignation.
michael kors bags nets jersey true religion outlet toms outlet hermes outlet asics michael kors purses nike.com burberry handbags new balance hogan los angeles clippers ugg true religion the north face nfl lions air max longchamp outlet milwaukee bucks nfl saints prada sunglasses ray-ban sunglasses nfl packers puma outlet store north face washington wizards cheap jerseys bcbg dresses abercrombie prada rayban rayban north face outlet marc jacobs outlet canada gooses outlet north face pas cher michael kors black friday nike free 5.0 air max 2014 mont blanc pens scarpe hogan polo ralph lauren designer handbags longchamp outlet ralph lauren burberry outlet online kevin durant shoeskobe bryant shoes michael kors outlet online sale beats by dre michael kors bags hollister kids cheap true religion nfl texans nike online nfl ravens calvin klein true religion jeans outlet coach factory online coach outlet michael kors bags coach purses cheap true religion ralph lauren shirts rayban sunglasses nike roshe bos jersey prada handbags oakley prescription uggs clothing websites hollister co coach factory outlet online longchamp omega watches juicy couture clothings hollister abercrombie woolrich outlet online ugg australia tommy hilfiger online shop nfl buccaneers ray ban wayfarer fendi outlet online levis outlet store flat iron puma uggs ralph lauren uk ed hardy clothing nfl jets nike air max 2015 oakley outlet toms.com jimmy choo ugg australia ralph lauren factory store baseball jerseys cheap jerseys mcm outletwlpwlp
uggs outlet
ralph lauren uk
ralph lauren
coach outlet
doudoune moncler
coach factory outlet
chanel bags
mont blanc
oklahoma city thunder jerseys
stivali ugg
vans shoes
canada goose sale
canada goose
ugg outlet
miami heat jerseys
uggs outlet
michael kors outlet
ray ban wayfarer
timberland boots
michael kors handbags
michael kors handbags
ray ban sunglasses
true religion outlet
louis vuitton outlet stores
ugg slippers on sale
louis vuitton outlet
nike air max
adidas superstars
coach outlet online
burberry handbags
prada handbags
tod's shoes
uggs on sale
lunettes ray-ban
tiffany and co
louis vuitton
louis vuitton outlet
true religion jeans outlet
chicago bulls jerseys
pandora jewelry
gucci outlet online
louis vuitton handbags
ralph lauren
yeezy boost 350
oakley sunglasses
abercrombie and fitch
timberland outlet
ugg boots
pandora outlet
ray ban sunglasses
louis vuitton outlet online
gucci outlet
michael kors handbags
louis vuitton outlet
beats by dre
replica rolex watches
uggs for women
louis vuitton handbags
coach outlet
coach outlet store online clearances
hollister clothing
coach outlet
ugg outlet
mont blanc pens cheap
coach outlet
mont blanc pens
new york knicks jerseys
christian louboutin outlet
ugg boots
ugg outlet
cheap oakley sunglasses
ugg boots clearance
ray bans
christian louboutin shoes
ugg boots
cheap jordans
red bottoms
nike roshe run
ralph lauren polo
louis vuitton handbags
fitflop shoes
ugg boots
san antonio spurs jerseys
rolex watches
jordan retro
michael kors outlet
cheap oakley sunglasses
michael kors outlet
michael kors handbags
louis vuitton outlet
hollister uk
louis vuitton pas cher
ugg boots clearance
hollister clothing
tory burch handbags
air jordan shoes
cheap ray ban sunglasses
nba jerseys
michael kors outlet
the north face jackets
cheap uggs
ugg boots uk
coach outlet
ugg sale
canada goose outlet
longchamp outlet
louis vuitton handbags
nike outlet
ray ban sunglasses
uggs for cheap
washington wizards jerseys
hollister clothing
nike outlet store
christian louboutin uk
tommy hilfiger outlet
michael kors outlet clearance
ugg boots
gucci handbags
prada outlet
true religion outlet
abercrombie
ray ban sunglasses
louis vuitton outlet
sac longchamp
christian louboutin outlet
cheap uggs
canada goose outlet
ugg boots
juicy couture
michael kors handbags
coach outlet
louboutin shoes
nike air max 2016
longchamp handbags
christian louboutin paris
rolex watches
cheap ray ban sunglasses
christian louboutin outlet
jordan shoes
north face outlet
ugg outlet
designer handbags
adidas shoes
gucci outlet
ugg boots
ugg outlet
ralph lauren outlet
louis vuitton canada
adidas yeezy
nfl jerseys wholesale
oakley sunglasses
pandora jewelry outlet
louis vuitton
rolex watches
fitflop sandals
louis vuitton bags
ugg boots
jordan shoes
louis vuitton handbags
coach outlet
michael kors outlet clearance
pittsburgh steelers jerseys
adidas trainers
louis vuitton
ralph lauren
pandora jewelry
ugg canada
oakley sunglasses
celine outlet
cheap ugg boots
ugg outlet
true religion jeans
coach outlet store online clearances
the north face outlet
hollister clothing store
supra sneakers
cheap rolex watches
louis vuitton uk
adidas originals
moncler jackets
ugg boots
louis vuitton outlet
cheap jordans
uggs sale
seattle seahawks jerseys
louis vuitton outlet
ugg outlet
ugg italia
fitflops
toms shoes
ray ban sunglasses
uggs outlet
louis vuitton handbags
seattle seahawks jerseys
cincinnati bengals jerseys
ugg boots
burberry sale
ray ban sunglasses
toms shoes
ugg boots
nike air max pas cher
polo ralph lauren
fitflops sale clearance
michael kors
coach outlet
ray ban sunglasses
moncler uk
canada goose outlet
louis vuitton
fitflops uk
polo ralph lauren
moncler uk
louis vuitton
coach outlet
coach outlet
adidas yeezy boost 350
coach outlet online
ray ban glasses
coach outlet
coach outlet online
canada goose sale
uggs pas cher
scarpe hogan
fitflops shoes
ugg australia
uggs
mulberry handbags
hilfiger outlet
canada goose
prada outlet
adidas nmd
louis vuitton outlet stores
ray ban sunglasses
canada goose jackets
ray ban sunglasses outlet
gucci outlet
ugg boots
rolex watches outlet
giuseppe zanotti shoes
cheap ugg boots
louboutin femme
true religion jeans
cheap uggs
cleveland cavaliers jerseys
coach factory outlet
burberry outlet
christian louboutin
ed hardy clothing
kate spade
rolex watches
hermes bags
coach outlet
clarisonic
chanel bags
louis vuitton handbags
louis vuitton outlet
ugg boots
adidas outlet
uggs outlet
coach outlet store online clearances
michael kors outlet
michael kors outlet
cheap toms shoes
ugg outlet
dallas mavericks jerseys
ugg australia
canada goose outlet
louboutin shoes
fitflop shoes
ugg canada
ugg boots sale
louis vuitton
coach outlet
canada goose jackets
oakley sunglasses outlet
coach outlet store online
adidas nmd
asics shoes
nike roshe run flyknit
louis vuitton outlet
christian louboutin sale
gucci outlet online
oakley sunglasses
canada goose jackets
boston celtics jerseys
canada goose sale
canada goose outlet
louis vuitton
canada goose outlet
coach factory outlet
ugg australia
uggs outlet
nike trainers
uggs outlet
timberland boots
ghd flat iron
christian louboutin shoes
canada goose outlet
moncler jackets
minnesota vikings jerseys
louis vuitton outlet
cheap nfl jerseys
north face outlet
uggs uk
oakley sunglasses
ugg sale
michael kors outlet online sale
true religion outlet
toms shoes
cheap oakley sunglasses
kate spade
denver broncos jerseys
mcm bags
coach bags
ugg boots
polo ralph lauren
ugg boots
ugg uk
toms sale
adidas superstar
ugg boots
chaussures ugg
ugg boots clearance
jordan femme
cheap ugg boots
curry 3
kate spade outlet
jordan shoes
air max sale
instyler max
moncler pas cher
louis vuitton outlet
mlb jerseys
ray ban sunglasses
nike roshe run
louis vuitton outlet
replica watches
ugg slippers
air jordan pas cher
cheap jordan shoes
louis vuitton bags
mbt shoes clearance
uggs sale
ray ban sunglasses
oakley sunglasses
michael kors
polo outlet
cheap jordans
uggs sale
canada goose jackets
canada goose
nike tn pas cher
abercrombie and fitch
uggs for men
golden state warriors jerseys
burberry outlet
kate spade handbags
uggs on sale
michael kors outlet
michael kors outlet
uggs outlet
coach outlet store online clearances
louis vuitton handbags
coach outlet online
coach outlet
uggs on sale
ugg boots
mbt shoes
ray ban sunglasses
coach factory outlet
nike outlet
fitflops sale clearance
celine bags
ugg boots outlet
oakley vault
ralph lauren uk
canada goose outlet
cheap nfl jerseys
louis vuitton outlet
toms shoes
pandora jewelry outlet
canada goose outlet store
louis vuitton outlet
adidas shoes
nhl jerseys
ray ban glasses
ugg boots
tiffany and co
ugg boots outlet
michael kors outlet
true religion jeans
new england patriots jerseys
basketball shoes
ralph lauren polo
toms outlet
true religion jeans
toms wedges
oakley sunglasses
los angeles clippers jerseys
doudoune canada goose
gucci handbags
louis vuitton outlet
christian louboutin pas cher
mont blanc pens
uggs outlet
chenlili20161108